Skip to main content

History of Heinen’s Premium Meats: A 90 Year Legacy

Joe Heinen in the Meat department
January 20, 2019

This post was inspired by an interview with Tom Heinen and Director of Meat, Eric Besselman

When you walk into Heinen’s, your options for filling your pantry, refrigerator and freezer are endless! However, the Heinen’s we know today did not always look like this, in fact, Heinen’s actually started as a butcher shop!

As we celebrate Heinen’s 90th Anniversary as a local, family-owned grocer, we’re looking back on how it all began with Joe Heinen and his commitment to sourcing high-quality meat.

Our story begins in 1921. After graduating from John Hay High School, young Joe Heinen took a job with Cleveland butcher, Mr. Dedreux. After learning the butchering trade, Heinen proposed adding groceries to the butcher shop so customers could do all of their shopping in one place. Mr. Deadreux was not keen on the idea, but Heinen believed that the community would appreciate his vision.

Heinen took his butchering skills and opened his own shop near Kinsman and Lee in Cleveland’s Shaker Heights neighborhood, and eventually added groceries in 1933.

Heinen was certainly ahead of his time for expanding product variety, but he also set the local standard for customer service and product quality.

When it came to the customer, Heinen ensured that each shopper’s meat buying experience was unique to them by being a local pioneer for custom cutting and personalized service, a process that our butchers uphold today. He believed that you had to find the best to sell the best, which sparked his commitment to having a hands-on role in the sourcing and production process of all of his meats. From lunch meat to ham, bacon and sausage, Heinen smoked all of his own meat in a smokehouse installed in his second store on Taylor Road.

When he was not smoking his own meats, he was traveling to the Akron stockyard to hand-select cattle. This was uncommon for a local grocer, but Heinen wanted to understand where his product was coming from to ensure that his unique standards were met. For example, although steers (male cows) offered more meat, Heinen always opted for heifers (female cows) because the eye (the muscle that runs through the middle of the animal and produces rib roasts, strip loins and tenderloins) was of much higher quality for his customers. This made him very popular in the Cleveland area.

Since Joe Heinen’s time, much has changed in Heinen’s Meat Department from how we handle our meat to what product our customers prefer:

  • People Prefer Poultry: Although ground beef continues to be our most commonly bought meat item, with over 40% of our meat products being ground beef, overall beef purchases have radically decreased compared to poultry.
  • Quartered & Hung vs. Pre-Packaged: Back in the early days of Heinen’s, beef was quartered and hung out in open air. To improve efficiency, as well as the quality and longevity of our products, Heinen’s meat is prepared and safely packaged by our meat experts at our new state-of-the-art manufacturing facility in Warrensville Heights.
  • Fat is not Favored: In the late 70’s, when Tom and Jeff Heinen entered the family business, the trim on a piece of meat was typically 1/4-inch thick. Today, people prefer trims around 1/8-inch thick or meat with no fat cover at all.
  • We Love Lean: A traditional cut of pork is around 40% leaner today than in Joe Heinen’s time.
  • Marbling is not Always a Must: While many people believe that a great steak has to have strong marbling, good genetics and proper feed can produce a phenomenal steak.
  • Local, Organic and Grass-Fed: In 1929, meat was not nearly as diverse as it is today. With the help of generations of meat experts, Heinen’s made a commitment to sourcing organic, local and grass-fed meat to meet the needs of our customers.

Although the meat industry has seen many changes since Joe Heinen opened his first butcher shop, 90 years later, we continue to follow his “buy the best to sell the best” philosophy.

Our meat team is often on the go, taking frequent trips to visit our partners and experience their operations firsthand to ensure that we are bringing the best meats to our customers. It doesn’t stop with simply knowing our sources, our team also takes great caution in personally handling our meat to ensure that each and every cut is to our specifications.

It is unique, strong-rooted standards, such as these, that have allowed Heinen’s meat to be a foundational element in our 90-year legacy.

By Heinen's Grocery Store
In 1929, Joe Heinen opened the doors of a small butcher shop on the east side of Cleveland, Ohio, aiming to establish himself as the city’s purveyor of quality meats. As customers came into Heinen’s new shop for their meat purchases, they began asking him to carry groceries as well. Joe added homemade peanut butter, pickles and donuts and by 1933, business had grown enough to include a line of produce and canned goods. Heinen’s Grocery Store was born.

This site is not optimized for your current browser (Internet Explorer 11).

Please switch to one of the following browsers for a complete viewing experience:

Chrome Logo Chrome Firefox Logo Firefox Edge Logo Edge